Supreme Court says senior BJP members should face criminal conspiracy charges
Three senior members of India’s ruling Hindu nationalist party including a cabinet minister should face trial over the demolition of a mosque a quarter of a century ago, the Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday.
The three are accused of inciting Hindu zealots to pull down the 16th century Babri mosque in Ayodhya in 1992, igniting one of India’s most explosive religious disputes in which thousands died.
India’s top court said government minister Uma Bharti, former deputy prime minister L. K. Advani, and M. M. Joshi—all senior members of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)—should face criminal conspiracy charges.
The ruling came after a lower court dropped the charges brought against them by India’s Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), kicking off a series of appeals and counter-appeals. “We have allowed the CBI appeal against the Allahabad High Court judgment with certain directions,” the Press Trust of India news agency quoted the Supreme Court judges as saying.
The demolition of the mosque in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh sparked nationwide riots in which thousands were killed, most of them Muslims. It marked the culmination of a virulent campaign led by the BJP, which recently won elections in the state, India’s largest.
Many Hindus believe the Babri mosque was only built after the destruction of a temple that marks the birthplace of their god Ram and the issue remains hugely divisive.
Some BJP leaders including Bharti want a temple to Ram to be built on the ruins of the razed mosque—an idea that horrifies Uttar Pradesh’s significant Muslim minority. Bharti, India’s water resources minister, said after the ruling she was “ready to hang” for the temple cause and would travel to Ayodhya later Wednesday. “There was no conspiracy. Everything was out in the open for everyone to see,” she told reporters. “I am absolutely clear about one thing—I have always been very proud of my participation in the Ram temple movement. I am ready to hang, to go to jail for this.”
Advani, now 89, has consistently denied a criminal conspiracy to destroy the mosque. The former leader of the BJP was in Ayodhya on the day of the demolition and his campaign for the temple came to define his political career. But in a later interview with the BBC, Advani said it should never have happened and described it as the saddest day of his life.
He has been tipped to be India’s president when the role becomes vacant later this year, but local media said the charges could scupper his chances.
The Supreme Court ordered that the case, which has dragged on since charges were first filed in 1993, should be completed within two years. However some legal experts expressed fears it would drag on longer.
“There are hundreds of witnesses in the case and now all of them will have to be re-examined,” said IB Singh, a senior lawyer who cross-examined Advani for the official enquiry into the Babri demolition. “I doubt if this will anyway get over within the lifetime of Mr. Advani.”
The opposition Congress said the ruling party had “tried every trick in the book” to ensure that Advani, Bharti and Joshi did not face charges. “What they [the Supreme Court] have said today means there’s clinching evidence that needs to be now argued out in the court,” said party spokesman Sanjay Jha.
The court also ruled that a fourth senior BJP politician, Kalyan Singh, who was leader of Uttar Pradesh at the time of the incident, should face criminal conspiracy charges. His trial, however, will be delayed until his stint as governor of Rajasthan state is over because the position of governor gives him immunity from prosecution.